The Near Loss of English Benedictine Hood

The hood is a distinguishing feature of the habit of the English Benedictines. It is detachable, not attached to either scapular or cowl (though centuries ago it was for a time), and is split or open at the front with long draping flaps at the front, affectionately or irritably (it depends on the monk you’re speaking to) known as elephant’s ears, and reaching to point more than halfway down the back (the tippet). It is not practical though it does at least cover the head well enough, unlike the micro-hoods we see on some religious habits today.

For those who are keen and have access to The Downside Review, Dom Oswald Sumner offers a history of the EBC habit over a number of issues in the mid-1940s. In brief, the EBC hood appears to be the child of the medieval English hood—itself deriving from the furred almuce still found in some orders of canons, but modified to distinguish monks from these canons—and the Spanish hood as it was at the time of the refounding of the EBC in 1605. At one period a huge and shapeless mess it has been refined to the strange if not totally inelegant thing we see today (not inelegant when worn properly, and that is by no means a universal phenomenon).

14369037_1286911941333153_1365507679_n
St Benedict with generously-proportioned elephant’s ears.
Of course the EBC was until well into the nineteenth century largely associated with and involved in missionary work, at first in England and Wales and later into the Indian Ocean and Australia. Given the penal laws in England, wearing a habit was not an option except in the monasteries themselves in France and Germany. In the wake of the French Revolution habits were discarded in the chaos, and were unknown among the brethren in England. Only the German house at Lambspringe, the EBC’s only abbey until 1900, held on to the habit until that community was suppressed in 1802.

blogIMG_20170503_204103_01
More modestly sized elephant’s ears, and a pleasing aesthetic when raised
It was at this point that the hood was almost lost. The monks of St Gregory’s (then at Acton Burnell and now at Downside) were seeking to make some habits but their plans were derailed. A letter from Dom Raymund Eldridge at Acton Burnell in 1807 to his confrere based in London, Dom Anselm Lorymer, succinctly exposes the crisis:

Br Francis is quite disconsolate at the loss of the pattern for cutting out hoods. He cannot think how you could have been such a Goth as to demolish a piece of such high antiquity.

In 1846 the community of Downside successfully petitioned General Chapter to resume the habit. Both the tailor at Downside and Dame Scholastica Gregson of Stanbrook made attempts to recreate the hood. It is their efforts that spawned the modern EBC hood, which is certainly not exactly similar to the hood worn before the French Revolution. Over the decades the elephant’s ears have been tamed and the width across the shoulders reduced. In the various houses today there is a general uniformity in the hood save for differing lengths of the elephant’s ears, and the Ampleforth/St Louis button fastening, as opposed to the hook-and-eye used by the other houses.

Older-Monks
These Ampleforth brethren model both the deluxe and the economy cuts of the hood
Whether our hood was worth the effort of saving is a debate for another time. Yet we can all agree that, however much we might like the gothic, we should strive never to be a Goth.

**PS Our late Fr Robert Richardson used often to wear a hood with a button, which got me one day to asking him why his hood was not of the hook and eye variety traditional at Douai. He replied that for a period in the 1930s, from when his hood dated!, Downside was out of favour at Douai. The Downside Stirs and that community’s general trend to exalt the cloister over the mission was not well received by the mission-centric Douai community. So we ditched the hook and eye and took up the button. However, it was not long before Ampleforth’s uppityness irked the Douai fathers, and we went back to hook and eye, where we remain to this day.**

8 thoughts on “The Near Loss of English Benedictine Hood

    1. Thank you. From memory, Ealing tends to extravagance rather than niggardliness in the hood, though nothing outré of course. I should have paid more attention to Fr Peter’s when he was here this week!

      Like

  1. I know best the hoods of the French Benedictines of St Joseph de Clairval & Fontgombault both of which seem attached to the scapular & (IMHO) neater than those of the English Benedictines. I knew the monks of Fort Augustus & they always seemed to have difficulty controlling their hoods

    Like

    1. They are indeed attached to the scapular, and are obviously neater. But, like leather belts rather than cloth ones, they are a sing of a reformed congregation. For better or for worse, many in the EBC value being unreformed.

      Like

  2. I suspect most Orders went through various ‘updates’ to their habits. In the Order to which I belonged many decades ago, the ‘update’ was to eliminate the cloak. To us younger members at the time this was a ‘scandal’.

    In the early 60s in Rome it was customary to wear habits when attending classes at the Gregorian. I admired the Trinitarians who still stuck to tradition and wore their cloaks.

    Like

    1. Actually the EBC has not updated its habit, other than to add to it! Our habit now is the same as in 1945, for example. Most would not wear the Roman collar with it now, I grant you, but that change is not official.

      Like

    1. Patterns are hard to come by. Downside Abbey would have one, as would J&M Sewing in Newcastle, and probably even Watts in London. Tailors new to the hood like old ones to take apart and copy.

      Pax.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s